Leading Within Limits: Unpacking the Illusion of Autonomy in Academy School Leadership

Luke Cresswell

University of Suffolk, United Kingdom

Education Thinking, ISSN 2778-777X – Volume 5, Issue 1 – 2025, pp. 17–24. Date of publication: 19 December 2025.

Download full-text PDF

Cite: Cresswell, L. (2025). Leading within limits: Unpacking the illusion of autonomy in academy school leadership. Education Thinking, 5(1), 17–24.

https://pub.analytrics.org/article/22/

Declaration of interests: The author declares to have no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgements: This research would not have been possible without the generous participation of the senior leaders interviewed, whose insights and reflections underpin this work. I am grateful to the University of Suffolk for academic supervision and support.

Author’s note: Luke Cresswell is a PhD Candidate in Education at the University of Suffolk. This article uses research from the author’s doctoral thesis, that explores school leadership experiences within Multi-Academy Trusts (MATs) in England. l.cresswell@uos.ac.uk

Copyright notice: The author of this article retains all his rights as protected by copyright laws.

Journal’s areas of research addressed by the article: 19-Education Policy; 20-Educational Administration and Management; 23-Educational Leadership.

Abstract

Schools led by English Multi-Academy Trusts (MATs) are presented in policy as models of autonomy and innovation. Yet, the lived experiences of senior leaders reveal a leadership environment characterised by centralised control, bureaucratic oversight, and constrained professional discretion. This paper explores the paradoxical tensions shaping MAT leadership through qualitative research informed by constructivist theory. Semi-structured interviews with thirteen senior leaders across Suffolk expose a systemic misalignment between the rhetoric of school autonomy and the realities of trust governance. These paradoxes manifest as tensions between autonomy and centralisation, identity and performativity, and democratic versus technocratic control, generating emotional labour, identity conflict, and diminished agency.

This paper makes an original contribution by conceptualising MAT leadership as “leading within limits” – a form of constrained agency produced through overlapping visible, hidden, and internalised power dynamics. Through a novel synthesis of Giddens’ Third Way, Lukes’ three-dimensional view of power, and Foucault’s governmentality, the study demonstrates how leaders not only navigate but also internalise the very constraints that restrict their autonomy.

The findings call for a reframing of school leadership policy that goes beyond market-driven performance to professional integrity and the emotional and ethical realities of leading in academised systems. This reconceptualisation is essential if the promises of academisation are to be realised in practice rather than remain rhetorical ideals.

Keywords

Academisation, Multi-Academy Trusts, Paradox theory, School autonomy, School governance, School governmentality, School leadership.

Education has long been central to political agendas in England, famously encapsulated by Tony Blair’s 1997 mantra: “Education, education, education” (Coughlan, 2007). Education not only shapes individual life chances but also acts as a mechanism through which nations define themselves, reproduce cultural values, and organise future prosperity (Ward & Eden, 2009). As such, it is a deeply political domain, influenced by a wide array of stakeholders including governments, communities, commercial actors, and policy entrepreneurs.

In England, debates about school governance, who controls funding, curriculum, and decision-making, have intensified with the rise of academisation. Initially introduced by New Labour in 2000 as a targeted intervention for schools serving disadvantaged communities, academies are now the dominant model favoured by successive governments (Department for Education, 2010). This shift has fundamentally restructured governance, leadership, and accountability in state education (Ball, 2012; Gunter, 2011).

Academies operate outside local authority oversight and are governed instead by Multi-Academy Trusts (MATs): corporate-style organisations responsible for multiple schools (Bernardinelli et al., 2018). Advocates argue that MATs enable greater autonomy, innovation, and responsiveness to local communities – freed from the “bureaucracy and constraints” of local authority governance (West & Wolfe, 2018). Yet emerging research points to a contrasting reality in which MATs intensify managerialism, centralise authority, and heighten accountability pressures, narrowing leaders’ professional agency and impacting their wellbeing (Courtney, 2015; Wilkins, 2011).

These conditions generate a key paradox: school leaders are held responsible for outcomes but increasingly constrained in decision-making by trust-level systems, surveillance, and performance cultures (Ball et al., 2012; Keddie, 2016). Research has shown how such performative environments reshape professional identities, generating emotional labour and tensions between leaders’ personal values, ethical commitments, and managerial expectations (Maxwell & Riley, 2016; Sachs, 2016).

Theoretical Framework

The theoretical framework of this study is threefold. First, Giddens (1998) “Third Way” theory is used to interpret academisation as part of neoliberal policy that simultaneously combines the institutions of the state and the market. This new type of policy attempted to unite traditional social justice with economic competitiveness. This view allows this research to reflect academisation as a way of balancing such seemingly opposing values through hybrid governance, which is emblematic of socio-political changes more broadly within welfare and public services (Ball, 2013; Giddens, 1998).

Second, Lukes (2004) three-dimensional view of power is incorporated to help measure and explain power. Lukes (2004) synthesises views of power into the visible, hidden, and invisible, which enable this paper to view the structure and process of power and effects as a comprehensive analytical lens for this research. Lukes (2004) also sees a role for consciousness raising in the struggle over power. The three-dimensional view of power accounts for different, mostly unseen, forms of exercising power as not just over people but also as a set of social relations and has thus been used in this review of literature to identify and understand how power is experienced and interpreted by MATs and their leaders (Ball, 2012; Lukes, 2004).

Third, Foucault’s (1991) theory of governmentality has been used to provide a wider understanding of power relations and different mechanisms in organisations. This perspective helps to view the power relations in MATs, structures, and processes in how power is reproduced as exercised over individuals by shaping self-relationships, rule of normative frameworks, and system of data use. This power lens helps to interpret how academy leaders self-regulate their conduct by conforming to MAT and regulatory expectations of accountability (Foucault, 1991; Lingard et al., 2016).

Study Purpose

This study examines the lived experiences of MAT senior leaders in Suffolk and how they navigate these tensions in their everyday work. Drawing on Giddens’ (1998) Third Way, Lukes’ (2004) three-dimensional view of power, and Foucault’s (1991) notion of governmentality, it analyses how power operates within MAT structures – both visibly through governance processes and invisibly through internalised norms of accountability.

Against this backdrop, the study seeks to understand how MAT senior leaders interpret and enact their roles within an increasingly centralised and performative governance landscape. Specifically, it investigates: (1) how leaders experience and negotiate tensions between autonomy and accountability; (2) how power dynamics shape identity, professionalism, and decision-making; and (3) how leaders make sense of, resist, or accommodate trust-level demands. By foregrounding the voices of those leading in MATs, this research contributes new insights into the micropolitics of educational leadership and informs wider debates about democratic governance, professional autonomy, and the future direction of academisation in England’s school system.

Method

The research design is qualitative and interpretive, drawing on constructivist theory (Charmaz, 2006). The methodology is fit for purpose in answering the research questions, which focus on the experiences of senior leaders in leading within MATs. The chosen theoretical lens supports the process of interpretation, helping to make sense of the meaning-making of participants, and provides space for the researcher to take up their role as interpreter of that data. This perspective also helps to balance the development of theory ‘emerging’ from data with an understanding that any theory is co-constructed by researcher and participants, rather than being ‘discovered’.

Participants are the 13 senior leaders who took part in semi-structured interviews. Participants include two Chief Executive Officers, one Executive Headteacher, three Headteachers, three Deputy Headteachers, three Assistant Headteachers and one Director of Teaching and Learning. All had experience of working within the academy system, and provided depth of understanding about the practice, pressures and paradoxes of leadership at this level.

Interviews were structured around open-ended questions, which sought to capture and explore participants’ perceptions about autonomy, governance, accountability, professional identity, emotional labour, and leadership practices. Interviews were recorded, transcribed and coded in iterative cycles of initial and focused coding, with the constant comparison method supporting identification of themes across cases, and memo-writing facilitating the development of theoretical categories.

Ethical approval was sought from the University of Suffolk, and all participants provided informed consent. Pseudonyms were used to maintain the anonymity of participants and organisations. The process was designed to be reflexive, as a matter of interpretation of data, and also in understanding the researcher’s positionality as a former school leader in the English education system.

Methodologically, the study does not aim for generalisation but rather for theory. In this, it makes an addition to the existent literature by providing an interpretation of the ways in which leaders experience MAT governance, autonomy, and accountability.

Results

The thematic analysis of the data identified four interrelated paradoxes through which senior leaders in MATs experience the limitations of autonomy: (1) constrained autonomy; (2) fractured identity; (3) cultures of surveillance; and (4) intensified emotional labour. Each theme reveals how the rhetoric of autonomy is constrained in practice.

Constrained Autonomy

Leaders consistently described autonomy as constrained or conditional as well as heavily circumscribed. While academisation is framed as offering school-level freedom, decision-making authority is largely shifted to the trust, limiting school-level discretion. Autonomy was commonly characterised as ‘delegated,’ ‘conditional,’ or ‘bounded,’ with trust-wide policies and frameworks defining narrow corridors for action.

One leader summarised how autonomy exists only when performance is strong:

“Autonomy is conditional… you only get freedom if the results look good. As soon as data dips, decisions get taken off you.” – Steve

These reflections highlight a fundamental gap between the policy claims of autonomy and lived professional reality.

Fractured Identity

The constraints on autonomy directly influenced professional identity. Leaders reported tensions between personal values and the performative demands of MAT governance, often suppressing ethical or community-oriented aspects of leadership.

One leader articulated the emotional disappointment of role progression:

“For me, the cost of attaining a leadership position was a bit of a let-down… emotionally, it didn’t seem worth it.” – Richard

This performative dissonance reinforces the sense that autonomy is nominal rather than substantive.

Cultures of Surveillance

Autonomy was further undermined by pervasive monitoring and accountability regimes. Rigorous performance management systems produced internalised self-surveillance.

One leader emphasised how accountability is felt even without explicit oversight:

“They’re not put on by anyone… but I know exactly what I’m expected to achieve.” – Helen

These accounts reflect how surveillance becomes embedded and normalised – performativity as self-discipline.

Emotional Labour and Wellbeing

The cumulative effects of constrained autonomy, fractured identity, and self-surveillance created a heavy emotional burden for leaders. The demands of the role extended far beyond the school gates, blurring the boundaries between personal and professional life and leaving little space for genuine rest or recovery. Even moments intended for rest were described as being overshadowed by the persistent awareness of expectations:

“Off-duty days… you’re still bound by a certain expectation.” – David

Together, these experiences illustrate how the emotional demands of leadership in Multi-Academy Trusts are both intense and deeply personal – shaping not only how leaders work, but how they live.

Emotional labour is therefore both structural and affective, namely an ongoing negotiation between accountability and care.

Together, these themes suggest that the autonomy promised under academisation is largely illusory. Structural control, performative cultures, surveillance, and emotional demands interconnect to shape leadership as a constant negotiation of paradox – leading within limits.

Discussion

This discussion examines how senior leaders in Multi-Academy Trusts navigate the significant paradoxes reshaping educational leadership in England. The findings reveal how structural reforms designed to increase autonomy simultaneously generate new constraints that reshape leaders’ professional agency, identity, and wellbeing. Using Giddens’ (1998) Third Way, Lukes’ (2004) multidimensional power, and Foucault’s (1991) governmentality as analytical lenses, this study offers a nuanced critical perspective on leadership within academisation.

Giddens’ (1998) Third Way is useful for understanding the policy rhetoric framing MATs as offering both autonomy and accountability (Ball, 2013). However, the present study highlights how these dual logics create contradictions in practice. Autonomy becomes bounded and conditional, limited by performance metrics and centrally mandated directives (Courtney, 2015; West & Wolfe, 2018). The rhetoric of freedom obscures intensifying policy instruments and control mechanisms that restrict decision-making latitude at school level (Keddie, 2016).

Lukes’ (2004) three-dimensional model of power illuminates how MAT governance structures exert control. Visible power sits with trust boards and executives whose decisions centralise authority over curriculum, finance, and staffing. Hidden power shapes the agenda by prioritising performance and financial discipline over wellbeing or relational leadership (Ball et al., 2012). Invisible power emerges through the internalisation of performative norms, meaning leaders self-regulate according to expectations that may conflict with their values (Sachs, 2016).

Foucault’s (1991) concept of governmentality further explains how these systems work through leaders. Self-surveillance, performativity, and emotional regulation become everyday practices that align leaders with policy logics of efficiency and marketisation (Wilkins, 2019). Leaders thus participate in reproducing the very constraints that diminish their autonomy (Lingard et al., 2016).

Together, these frameworks show that the paradoxes experienced by MAT leaders are not incidental but embedded in the academisation project. Bounded autonomy, fractured identity, surveillance cultures, and emotional strain arise from systemic tensions between empowerment and control (Ball et al., 2012; Maxwell & Riley, 2016). Leadership in MATs is therefore a form of identity work negotiated within overlapping regimes of visible and invisible power (Courtney, 2015; Sachs, 2016).

This study contributes three original insights to the field:

It conceptualises MAT leadership as ‘constrained agency’ – where responsibility increases while meaningful decision-making power contracts.

It exposes the emotional and ethical dimensions of academisation, showing wellbeing and professional identity as central – not peripheral – to policy effects.

It foregrounds the micropolitics of MAT governance by revealing how power is internalised and enacted in leaders’ daily practices, not only through structural reforms.

These contributions extend policy debates by shifting attention from organisational performance to the human consequences of reform.

Implications for policy and practice are clear. Claims of autonomy in MATs must be matched by genuine decision-making power rather than intensified oversight (Bernardinelli et al., 2018). Leadership preparation should address the emotional, ethical, and political contexts of MAT work – not just the technical demands (Maxwell & Riley, 2016). Trust boards should reconsider governance approaches to support professional judgment, relational leadership, and democratic accountability (Keddie, 2016).

Importantly, paradox should not be seen as a failure of leadership but an inherent feature of the academised system. A more humane model recognises that effective leadership involves living with tension, prioritising trust and integrity over compliance and competition (Ball, 2012; Sachs, 2016).

Conclusion

This study has revealed how leadership within Multi-Academy Trusts (MATs) is defined less by promised autonomy and more by the persistent negotiation of structural constraint. Although academisation is framed as a strategy to empower schools, the findings demonstrate that centralised governance and intensifying accountability create constrained agency: leaders hold responsibility without the freedom to act upon it.

Using the combined perspectives of Giddens’ Third Way, Lukes’ dimensions of power, and Foucault’s governmentality, this research shows how control in MATs operates not only through explicit regulation but also through subtle forms of agenda-setting, self-surveillance, and internalised performativity. These mechanisms reshape leadership identities, erode authenticity, and intensify emotional labour, effects that are experienced personally but produced systemically.

The implications are clear: if MATs are to fulfil their promise of improving equity and excellence, governance must shift from command-and-control accountability towards trust-based professional autonomy where leadership development needs to engage seriously with the ethical, emotional, and political nature of contemporary school leadership, better preparing leaders to challenge, rather than simply absorb, the pressures of performativity.

This research makes an original contribution by foregrounding paradox and identity work as central to MAT leadership, exposing how leaders are simultaneously empowered and constrained, valued and put under surveillance, visible and voiceless and how to lead within limits is now the defining reality of MAT leadership.

A more humane and democratic future for English education will depend on whether leadership is permitted not merely to comply with the system, but to change it.

References

Ball, S. J. (2012). Global Education Inc.: New policy networks and the neo-liberal imaginary. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203803301

Ball, S. J. (2013). The education debate. 2nd edition. Policy Press.

Ball, S. J., Maguire, M., & Braun, A. (2012). How schools do policy: Policy enactments in secondary schools. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203153185

Bernardinelli, D., Rutt, S., Greany, T., & Higham, R. (2018). Multi-academy trusts: Do they make a difference to pupil outcomes? London: UCL IOE Press. 978-1-78277-253-8

Charmaz, K. (2006). Constructing Grounded Theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. Sage.

Coughlan, S. (2007). Education, education, education. BBC News. Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/6564933.stm (Accessed: 14 December 2025).

Courtney, S. J. (2015). Corporatised leadership in English schools. Journal of Educational Administration and History, 47(3), 214–231.

https://doi.org/10.1080/00220620.2015.1038694.

Department for Education. (2010). The importance of teaching: The Schools White Paper 2010. London: Department for Education.

Foucault, M. (1991). Governmentality. In G. Burchell, C. Gordon, & P. Miller (Eds.). The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality (pp. 87–104). University of Chicago Press.

Giddens, A. (1998). The Third Way: The renewal of social democracy. Polity Press.

Gunter, H. M. (2011). Leadership and the reform of education. Policy Press.

https://doi.org/10.1332/policypress/9781847427670.001.0001,

Keddie, A. (2016). Academisation, school collaboration and the primary school sector in England: A story of six school leaders. School Leadership & Management, 36(2), 169–183. https://doi.org/10.1080/13632434.2016.1196174

Lingard, B., Martino, W., & Rezai-Rashti, G. (2016). Testing regimes, accountabilities and education policy. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315666082

Lukes, S. (2004). Power: A radical view. 2nd edition. Palgrave Macmillan.

Maxwell, A., & Riley, P. (2016). Emotional demands, emotional labour and occupational outcomes in school principals: Modelling the relationships. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 45(3), 484–502.

https://doi.org/10.1177/1741143215607878 (Original work published 2017)

Sachs, J. (2016). Teacher professionalism: Why are we still talking about it? Teachers and Teaching, 22(4), 413–425. DOI: 10.1080/13540602.2015.1082732

Ward, S., & Eden, C. (2009). Key issues in education policy. Sage.

West, A., & Wolfe, D. (2018). Academies, the school system in England and a vision for the future. Clare Market Papers (23). London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK. ISBN 9781909890428

Wilkins, A. (2011). School choice and the commodification of education: A visual approach to school brochures and websites. Critical Social Policy, 32(1), 69–86.

https://doi.org/10.1177/0261018311425199

Wilkins, A. (2019). The processual life of neoliberalisation: Permutations of value systems and normative commitments in a co-operative trust setting. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 23(11), 1180–1195.

https://doi.org/10.1080/13603116.2019.1629158

Share this Post